10 Best Gourmet Christmas Cookies To Order Online - The Three Snackateers (2024)

The Best Gourmet Christmas Cookies To Order Online

1. Bake Me A Wish

Nothing says Happy Holidays like adorable snowman cookies! These cute little guys start with a base of handmade butter cookies. They are covered in vanilla frosting and then decorated with eyes, nose, hat, buttons and of course, a carrot nose.

You’ll also find other delicious seasonal treats like eggnog cheesecake, decorated holiday cupcakes, and Christmas-themed layer cakes.

I’m personally a huge fan of Bake Me A Wish. Of all the mail-order companies that I’ve tried, I’m always amazed at the level of care that goes into their packaging to make sure your order arrives in perfect shape. You can see some photos and read our review here.

2. Mrs. Fields

If you’re looking for festive Christmas cookies gifts, baskets and boxes, Mrs. Fields is a great place to look. They have a massive selection of cookie gifts like seasonal tins with messages like Happy Holidays, Merry Christmas and Peace Love & Cookies.

Their cookie towers also make quite a statement. Choose from The Nutcracker, polar bears, snowmen and more.

Also check out their themed cookie cakes and cute options like the gingerbread house shown in the photo above.

3. Baked By Melissa

Baked By Melissa is best known for its colorful bite-size cupcakes that come in fun and festive flavors like Christmas cookie, caramel hot cocoa and chocolate babka. But did you know they also offer equally adorable bite-size macarons?

These melt-in-your-mouth cookies come in flavors that are perfect for the holidays including sugar cookie, red velvet and snickerdoodle. Their macarons are made with almond flour so they are naturally gluten-free.

You can also check our Baked By Melissa review here.

4. Sugarwish

I think Forbes said it best … Sugarwish is “a choose-your-own treat adventure“! When you send a Sugarwish gift, you pick the eCard and your lucky recipient gets to customize the actual gift. How cool is that?

With their cookie gift, the person you’re sending it to gets to pick from a ton of delicious flavors. They’ll find traditional cookies like chocolate chip, peanut butter and sugar. Or they might want to gobble up some stuffed cookies like the stuffed red velvet or smores options.

Sugarwish also features seasonal favorite flavors that are perfect for the holidays. And if there are any special dietary concerns, they also offer some vegan, gluten-free and keto cookies as well.

5. Cookies By Design

If you’re looking for a gift that is both affordable and creative, look no further than Cookies By Design Christmas cookies. Their one-of-a-kind Christmas cookie baskets are available in so many fun designs that are perfect for holiday gifts.

The cookie bouquets and boutrays (bouquet plus a tray of cookies) are filled with hand-decorated cookie designs like Santa, snowmen, snowglobes, candy canes, stockings, gingerbread men and more. They also have some super cute decorated cookie cakes too.

Their cookie gifts come in several different sizes, so there are options to fit every budget.

6. Christie Cookies

Christie Cookies is a hometown Nashville bakery that prides itself on delivering cookies so good, you’ll write home about them.

To ensure every cookie is mouthwateringly delicious, they handcraft every batch and focus on just 5 classic flavors: chocolate chip, peanut butter chocolate chip, oatmeal raisin, snickerdoodle and rocky road.

Their gourmet gift tins are packed with cookies and some include triple chocolate brownies too. You can choose from a variety of designs ranging from a simple Happy Holidays to cute themes like Baking Spirits Bright and Good Tidings We Bake.

Their custom design options are really great if you need a corporate cookie gift or a logo cookie gift.

7. David’s Cookies

David’s Cookies is one of the best-known cookie companies out there and for good reason. They’ve been baking up fresh cookies since 1979.

They offer delicious cookies packaged carefully in holiday-themed tins and crates specially designed for shipping. Their customer-favorite Butter Pecan Meltaways look like little powdered sugar snowballs and literally melt in your mouth. So good!

8. Cheryl’s Cookies

Chery’s Cookies is widely recognized as having some of the most delicious frosted sugar cookies out there. Their cut-out cookies come in a variety of seasonal designs and are frosted with soft delicious buttercream featuring colors and sprinkles to celebrate the season.

You can select from large gift baskets, tins and towers filled with cookies and other gourmet bakery treats like brownies, bars and cake slices.

Or for something more personal, they have some cute individually wrapped cookies like their holiday cookie card set and holiday treat ornaments.

9. Levain Bakery

Who wouldn’t want world-famous Levain cookies shipped to their door for Christmas? Levain Bakery is a New York City institution with an almost cult-like following of fans who adore their cookies.

If you can’t make it to one of the NYC locations, thankfully you can have their delicious cookies shipped nationwide. They will arrive in classy packaging with individually wrapped cookies inside that are tied with their iconic blue ribbon.

They offer classic flavors like two-chip chocolate chip, chocolate chip walnut, dark chocolate chocolate chip, dark chocolate peanut butter chip and oatmeal raisin.

They also added a new vegan and gluten-free chocolate chip walnut cookie in 2023.

For more details on their tasty cookies, you can get the scoop in our Levain Bakery review.

10. Goldbelly

Goldbelly is your one-stop shop for the best gourmet, mail-order foods that can be shipped nationwide … and that includes Christmas cookies!

Each year when the holiday season comes around, dozens of the country’s best bakeries list their desserts and sweet treats on Goldbelly for you to order online and have delivered to your door. Goldbelly is also the place where you can order the infamous Piecaken (pie baked in a cake).

You’ll find a huge selection of holiday cookies like gingerbread, traditional sugar cut-out cookies, and Italian rainbow cookies from famous, award-winning companies. It doesn’t get much sweeter than that!